Issues Navigator

Global Challenges

Strategic Regions

Domestic Debates

Tag cloud

See All Tags

June 26, 2010 |  2 comments |  Print  Your Opinion  

Ulf  Gartzke

Topic General McChrystal: Repeat Offender

Ulf Gartzke: General McChrystal’s “Rolling Stone” controversy may have caused shock, disbelief, and outrage across the United States, but to those following the former top US commander in Afghanistan since the beginning of his tenure, his downfall should not be a complete surprise. After all, in terms of mishandling the media, McChrystal is a repeat offender.

In September 2009, General McChrystal allowed a "Washington Post" reporter to accompany him and a seven-member NATO fact-finding team to the otherwise closed-door meetings with German troops and Afghan officials investigating a deadly Bundeswehr-ordered US airstrike on two Taliban-hijacked tanker trucks. Jumping on this golden opportunity, the "Post" promptly published an insider's account of the on-going NATO investigation in its Sunday edition, just two days after the air strike had happened, relaying estimates concerning the associated Taliban and civilian casualty figures, etc.

German political leaders and senior military officers were outraged at McChrystal's decision to bring a journalist to these internal, classified briefings, which took place just hours after the air strike. "It stinks to high heaven," one unnamed Bundeswehr officer told the "Neue Osnabrücker Zeitung" newspaper, which also reported that German commanders accused the US army of "deliberately leaking misinformation about an ongoing investigation". Chancellor Merkel was certainly not happy about the "Washington Post" story either and sharply criticized those who immediately pointed the finger at Germany's military leadership, stressing that she opposed making premature judgments and jumping to conclusions before all the results of the NATO investigation into civilian casualties, etc. were known.

In the months following the Kunduz air strike, General McChrystal was able to repair strained relations with Berlin and also seemed to have established a good personal connection with German defense minister Karl-Theodor zu Guttenberg. However, the bottom-line is: The "Rolling Stone" story is not the first time that General McChrystal has mishandled the media by giving a journalist unwarranted access to internal meetings and discussions. The first time around, of course, there were no immediate negative consequences for McChrystal, who may have wanted to use the "Washington Post" story to "reprimand" the Germans over the Bundeswehr's perceived violation of his zero civilian casualties policy. Whatever McChrystal's ultimate motivation, what goes around comes around and last time I checked, the term "Schadenfreude" was German.

Ulf Gartzke is a Visiting Scholar at Georgetown University's BMW Center for German and European Studies. This article reflects his personal opinion.

  • 5
  •  
  •  
  • No rating possible
  • No rating possible
I like this Article! What's this?

 
Tags: | media | Afghanistan | Kunduz | Germany | McChrystal |
 
Comments
Olga  Kolesnichenko

June 27, 2010

  • 1
  •  
  •  
  • No rating possible
  • No rating possible
I like this comment! What's this?
I very regret about General McChrystal dismissal from ISAF leadership. I think General McChrystal is the wise and experienced general. And I am sure that General McChrystal will be appointed soon to the high military post. I have written about General McChrystal for newspaper 'Military Industrial Courier ' in 2009. I know that General McChrystal had been served in Fort Bragg, North Carolina; Fort Benning, Georgia; South Korea (United Nations Command Support Group Joint Security Area); Fort Stewart, Georgia; OPERATIONS DESERT SHIELD/STORM, Saudi Arabia; Fort Lewis, Washington; Council on Foreign Relations, New York; Combined Joint Task Force Kuwait, Camp Doha; OPERATION ENDURING FREEDOM, Afghanistan; The Joint Staff, Washington.
General McChrystal has more than dozen decorations and also general has got 5 high-level diplomas: United States Military Academy; United States Naval War College; Salve Regina University; United States Naval Command and Staff College; Senior Service College Fellowship; John F. Kennedy School of Government, Harvard University, Cambridge, Massachusetts.
Link to my article-2009
http://www.vpk-news.ru/40-306/2009-05-02-13-24-04/3175

And I wonder why German general isn't able to be appointed to the position of head of ISAF in terms of Germany big contribution into Afghanistan mission?



 
Ann H. Sontz

June 29, 2010

  • 1
  •  
  •  
  • No rating possible
  • No rating possible
I like this comment! What's this?
Yes,General McChrystal is a much decorated military leader and,yes,he may have mishandled the media. Mishandling the media,however, is not the predominant reason behind his ultimate resignation.

Constitutionally, the military in the US is always subordinate to the Executive and Legislative
Branches of Government. It is the role of the military to follow policy, not to design it.

The General's interview statements, criticisms of policy approaches in and about Afghanistan,rightfully belonged in committee meetings, appropriate venues for his analyzes and advice based on a lengthy and distinguished military experience. Media presentations were decidedly inappropriate. Whether these conformed to general or specific public opinion in Afghanistan or among military holding other than US nationality,was probably not a determining factor in the General's case.
Tags: | General McCrystal |
 

Commenting has been deactivated in the archive. We appreciate your comments on our more recent articles at atlantic-community.org


Community

You are in the archive of all articles published on atlantic-community.org from 2007 to 2012. To read the latest articles from our open think tank and network with community members, please go to our new website