Issues Navigator

Global Challenges

Strategic Regions

Domestic Debates

Tag cloud

See All Tags

May 4, 2009 |  7 comments |  Print  Your Opinion  

Editorial Team

The Global Disease Challenge: Vote Here

Editorial Team: As Swine Flu captures the headlines, it emphasizes the threat posed by global diseases, and the concerted policy action they require. We are inviting you to vote for what you consider the most pressing disease.


Despite highly advanced medicines and a sophisticated understanding of infection, the modern disease challenge is as serious ever. However, the debate about what priorities the international community should have in their approach to global health threats is as contentious as ever.

Determining which disease to prioritize requires a careful analysis balancing infection numbers, death tolls and the debilitating effects on the community and infrastructure.

We are inviting you to vote for what you consider the most pressing disease challenge as a launch-pad for a discussion about the global health agenda.  Below is an overview of the challenges each of the diseases poses on the global scale: 

  1. Swine and Avian Flu

    With the recent outbreak of the Swine Flu in Mexico -- which contains genetic materials from the virus that usually affects birds and pigs -- international concern about the international virus epidemics are rising.  Indeed, when one considers European history, a prospect of an influenza pandemic on a scale which would dwarf the 1918 Spanish Flu is a frightening scenario. If the strains of the Swine or Avian flu mutate in the right way, it will be able to spread by human-to-human at an alarming rate. If such transmissions begin, a pandemic could occur which could affect between 2 million and 7.4 million people around the world. Such scenarios underline the seriousness of the threats.

    The WHO has provided recommended action plans to deal with an eventual pandemic and has a stockpile of 3 million antiretroviral treatments which it is hoped will delay the spread. Better surveillance, detection capacity, early-warning systems, investment in vaccine research and the ability to enforce movement restriction need to be put in place now on a national level if this strategy is to have any success. However, not enough countries have implemented the necessary protective measures against an influenza epidemic.
     
     
  2. Diseases of Poverty:

    a) Cholera

    Cholera, caused by bacteria residing in infected water, takes hold in areas with poor sanitation and inadequate access to safe drinking water. It causes profuse vomiting and diarrhea and is transmitted through contaminated food and drinks or contact with cholera patients. Immediate and constant hydration of the patient is required to prevent a death of dehydration.

    The disease could be contained and prevented with proper sanitation practices and a stronger health infrastructure in the developing world. Zimbabwe is a recent example. As political instability, collapse of the health infrastructure, obstacles to foreign aid combined in a tragic Cholera outbreak, which according to the WHO has surpassed 80,000 cases and caused over 3000 deaths.

    The immediate reaction necessitates a control of the outbreak regions and hydration treatments.  In the long-term the fight against cholera necessitates the development of proper sanitation practices, and an emphasis on preventative measures in development and aid programs. The failure to address cholera poses a threat to millions of lives and to the development prospects of countries across the globe.

    b) Tuberculosis

    Tuberculosis currently kills 2 million people a year and infects another 5 million. It is an infectious bacterial disease which spreads to the lungs and is fatal if left untreated. Developing countries are worst affected, and HIV/AIDS sufferers' poor immune systems put them at even greater risk: 30% of people living with HIV also have TB. The most deadly strains of the virus are those such as extremely drug-resistant Tuberculosis (XDR-TB), which are resistant to antibiotics. International action to improve TB control is urgently required.

    Access and equity are the key challenges: treatment plans are time consuming and cumbersome and thus particularly difficult for people in post-conflict regions to follow correctly. Self-administered treatment models and community observation schemes adapted to suit rural and nomadic patients have been launched by Doctors Without Borders. In addition, research into antibiotic resistance is needed. Grassroots activism such as the XDRTB.org initiative, which works to improve funding for TB diagnostics, combined with international backing for new research, such as the WHO DOTS strategy, need greater international backing.

    c) Malaria

    500 million people are affected by Malaria every year, 2 million are killed. In fact, one child dies from form Malaria every 80 seconds and it costs Africa $12 billion annually. In spite of this, it reminds neglected because it is not immediately threatening worldwide and does not receive the kind of "celebrity disease" status which HIV/AIDS does. Just 35 countries account for 98 percent of global malaria deaths, many of which are among the poorest in the world.

    Lack of political will and financial investment remain obstacles to the containment of the disease. Since the means to reduce malaria are already available, what is needed is concerted, coordinated global action. The Roll Back Malaria Partnership seeks to tackle malaria through a combination of prevention and cure: mosquito control strategies (insecticidal nets, residual sprays and clean water) preventative treatment during pregnancy, prompt diagnosis and anti-malarial treatment if necessary. Doctors Without Borders has had commendable success in overcoming cost barriers to obtaining diagnosis and treatment through training community malaria volunteers who can reach isolated areas and by providing free health care for those most at risk.
     

  3. HIV/AIDS

    HIV/AIDS has swept the globe with alarming speed and devastating consequences. Nearly 40 million people live with the virus worldwide and 2 million die from AIDS-related causes each year. It is a chronic infection which gradually debilitates the immune system; while death from AIDS can currently be stalled with antiretroviral drugs (ARVs), the disease cannot be cured. Despite the prominence of HIV/ Aids in the media, the battle persists to tackle the disease at all levels: diagnosis, prevention, drug therapy, counseling and vaccine research.

    Drug availability and affordability is one of the biggest obstacles to treatment in the developing world: whilst campaigns to lower prices of ARVS have had considerable success, newer drugs remain costly and subject to bureaucratic patent laws. UNITAID advocates tackling these barriers through the use of a "patent pool" and such innovative initiatives need international backing if they are to be successful. The sexual stigma attached to the disease poses a host of problems that other diseases do not face. The preventative approach, which in the absence of much progress towards a vaccine is the priority, is bound up with addressing cultural attitudes to sexuality and contraception. Resources should be put into simultaneously increasing reproductive education, particularly among females, and providing people with access to affordable antiretroviral treatment.
     
     
  4. Diseases of the Wealthy: Obesity and Some Kinds of Diabetes

    Western aid for diseases in the developing world will not even be available if the current obesity epidemic seizing Europe and North America is not addressed. The prevalence of obesity has tripled in many western countries since the 1980s and in the US, 61% of adults are overweight or obese; in the UK, 1 in 3. While the scale of the problem is slowly being acknowledged, governments are being too slow to act. Nothing short of a revolution in food culture is needed in conjunction with the promotion of free, safe, accessible exercise facilities.

    Heart disease and diabetes are the most severe obesity-related diseases, and worldwide numbers of the latter are set to increase from 192 million to 333 million by 2025. Lower socioeconomic groups are worst affected and long-term obesity not only increases morbidity but also puts an enormous burden on the economy's health service. Tackling this epidemic should take precedence over investing in diseases in the developing world; a national emergency is at hand and it is imperative that governments address this crisis.

     

  • 15
  •  
  •  
  • No rating possible
  • No rating possible
I like this Article! What's this?

 
Tags: | Doctors Without Borders | TB | cholera | AIDS | HIV | MAlaria | global disease | WHO |
 
Comments
Jennifer L. Amariya

April 29, 2009

  • 6
  •  
  •  
  • No rating possible
  • No rating possible
I like this comment! What's this?
Thank you for this interesting poll, diseases are a factor not often discussed in an International Relations context.
Clearly the fight against Malaria needs to be prioritized, as this is the lowest-hanging fruit in this list of diseases. As the medical technology already exists to fight this disease, it is simply a question of incentivizing distribution and investment. With sufficient political will, rapid progress could be made.
 
Bernhard  Lucke

April 29, 2009

  • 5
  •  
  •  
  • No rating possible
  • No rating possible
I like this comment! What's this?
Thank you for this interesting poll, and I'd like to point out that this is a very "hot" topic in research, since times of climate change have often been times of new pandemics.

I'm stunned by the current result of the poll, which sees Malaria as the most dangerous disease. It is certainly not - not even if the vectors migrate further north due to warming. Large parts of the world population posess genetic immunity against Malaria, and the development of a vaccine is in reach, but was not intentisified as the most likely customers are travelling white men. Also the death rate is not so high. It might be wise to intensify these programs, but other threats are more pressing.

There is an interesting nature article by Wolfe et al. on the matter, see http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v447/n7142/full/nature05775.html.

With regard to Mexico, it is important to note that about 80% of the indigenous population were killed between 1540 and 1580 by Cocolitzli, a local hemorraghic fever, and NOT by old world diseases imported by the Spaniards. Strangely, Europeans were rarely affected by this disease. See http://rmcg.unam.mx/20-3/(6)Heine.pdf

The "big killers" like plague emerged from mutations of animal pathogens just as the current swine flu. As pointed out by Wolfe et al. in their above mentioned paper in Nature, influenza is the most likely big killer, much more dangerous than Malaria, Cholera, or HIV. I would say "obesity" is not even worth mentioning in the context of plague death rates.

The historic appearance of plague was probably mostly (or always?) connected with swift and significant changes of the environment, which is why WHO is very much alarmed by global warming. Such diseases changed history, e.g. the Black Death, or Bubonic Plague 542-750 AD. We are not safe of such diseases, especially since world traffic is so intense, and the incubation time of some diseases might last years. The Mexican swine flu might have the potential to be the next big killer.

Interestingly, from a medical point things are only not well-clarified. The occurrence of a new pathogen does not necessarily mean that a pandemic evolves. I would say we simply don't know enough about viruses... and it is unknown why some people are not infected at all. In this context, alternative medicines like classic homeopathy offer stimulating thoughts.

I analysed some historic plague outbreaks and their environmental framework in my dissertation, which can be found at: http://opus.kobv.de/btu/volltexte/2007/343/


References:

Heine, K., 2003. Paleopedological evidence of human-induced environmental change in the Puebla-Tlaxcala area (Mexico) during the last 3,500 years. Revista Mexicana de Ciencias Geológicas, v. 20, núm. 3, 235-244.

Nathan D. Wolfe, Claire Panosian Dunavan & Jared Diamond, 2007. Origins of major human infectious diseases. Nature Vol 447, 17 May 2007, doi:10.1038/nature05775, 279-283.

Lucke, B., 2008. Demise of the Decapolis. Past and Present Desertification in the Context of Soil Development, Land Use, and Climate. VDM, Saarbrücken.
 
Rob  Steer

April 29, 2009

  • 1
  •  
  •  
  • No rating possible
  • No rating possible
I like this comment! What's this?
The media often neglects global health problems when they are "under the radar," and then proceeds to whip up a frenzy as has happened with Swine Flu in the last few days, and SARS, Avian Flu and Foot and Mouth in recent years.

This situation will be soon forgotten once it has disappeared from the headlines, but bigger problems such as those identified in the poll will continue to require addressing.

My own personal opinion is that more money should be invested in clean water and educational programmes to compliment medical research into finding vaccines for all of these serious diseases.
Tags: | Water | SARS | avian flu | swine flu | global health |
 
Roya  Sackniess

April 30, 2009

  • 5
  •  
  •  
  • No rating possible
  • No rating possible
I like this comment! What's this?
I am working for the European Alliance Against Malaria (www.europeanallianceagainstmalaria.org) which is campaigning for rigorous and resolute action against malaria as part of global efforts to reduce poverty and to achieve our vision of a malaria free world.

Malaria is one of the leading causes of death world-wide, especially in the developing world. But Malaria is entirely preventable and an integrated package of malaria control interventions that focuses on relatively simply but proven solutions can greatly reduce the suffering.

But significant funding gaps remain in each malaria endemic region and are four times the currently available funding. Malaria is still a neglected disease.

Thank you for giving us the possibility to issue a statement on that and to vote.

Tags: | MAlaria |
 
Ria  Voorhaar

April 30, 2009

  • 2
  •  
  •  
  • No rating possible
  • No rating possible
I like this comment! What's this?
Eradicating diseases that affect developing countries is surely the most important goal.

The fact that treatments exist for malaria and yet are not made freely available to the poor is unjust.

The work of Doctors Without Borders is to be commended, and I agree with Rob that it is a vital to invest in clean water and educational programmes to halt further outbreaks of such diseases.

However, I also think that the way we fund medical research and the way we deal with the breakthroughs achieved needs to be altered.

There must be more philanthropy and international or state-funded research that allows for the medical breakthroughs or drugs to be distributed to developing countries for free, and not exploited by pharmaceutical companies for decades before their broad release.

In addition, I think the media is bound by its responsibility to report the threat of a pandemic and its love of a good story... As a result, we get an often hysterical response to potential pandemics, but we at least know of their existence. Would it be worse not to know?

Ben Goldacre has an interesting comment piece on this in The Guardian today.
Tags: | pandemics | swine flu | SARS | avian flu |
 
Ivan  Kalburov

May 5, 2009

  • 1
  •  
  •  
  • No rating possible
  • No rating possible
I like this comment! What's this?
Let's see if we can turn the arguments upside down?
I think this post, as well as the whole media reaction in the last weeks is a classic example of securitization move. Phenomena that have been in place for so long are being overemphasized intentionally or not, which results in government measures in the field of security that target the same phenomena.
Examples from the recent years you can find easily among diseases and different type of natural disasters.
One should be certainly concerned with all these. But let me disagree with the question in the poll. I would ask to what extend should we be concerned? and to what extend should make security policies from media phenomena? Where are the boundaries of security ?
You can't disagree that the recent H1N1 hysteria is absolutely minuscule considering the rest of the natural disasters and man-made tragedies we currently have. Can you ?
 
Unregistered User

May 5, 2009

  • 2
  •  
  •  
  • No rating possible
  • No rating possible
I like this comment! What's this?
The issue is not which disease is the most important - that approach has led to the present fragmentation in the global health arena. The issue is how to build primary health systems in developing countries (including public health measures) so that people have access to a range of services, vaccinations and medications. For more background read Laurie Garrets recent article "The Global Health Challenge" in Foreign Affairs. January February 2007
 

Commenting has been deactivated in the archive. We appreciate your comments on our more recent articles at atlantic-community.org


Community

You are in the archive of all articles published on atlantic-community.org from 2007 to 2012. To read the latest articles from our open think tank and network with community members, please go to our new website